0.11/0.12 % Problem : theBenchmark.p : TPTP v0.0.0. Released v0.0.0. 0.11/0.13 % Command : run_portfolio.sh /export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p /export/starexec/sandbox2/tmp/tmp.Vgg1W6hg4u 0.13/0.34 % Computer : n010.cluster.edu 0.13/0.34 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 0.13/0.34 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz 0.13/0.34 % Memory : 8042.1875MB 0.13/0.34 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64 0.13/0.34 % CPULimit : 180 0.13/0.34 % DateTime : Thu Aug 29 13:15:51 EDT 2019 0.13/0.35 % CPUTime : 154.02/163.17 % Running portfolio for 180 s 154.02/163.17 % File : /export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p 154.02/163.17 % TempDir : /export/starexec/sandbox2/tmp/tmp.Vgg1W6hg4u 154.02/163.17 % Recognized as monomorphic HO. 154.02/163.17 % Running /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/competitive.sh for 18 154.02/163.17 % Running /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/competitive.2.sh for 13 154.02/163.17 % Running /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/competitive.3.sh for 3 154.02/163.17 % Running /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/pragmatic.rudimentary.sh for 28 154.02/163.17 % Running /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/pragmatic.rudimentary.1.sh for 12 154.02/163.17 % Running /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/pragmatic.rudimentary.2.sh for 7 154.02/163.17 % Running /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/pragmatic.shallow.sh for 3 154.02/163.17 % Running /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/pragmatic.shallow.1.sh for 15 154.02/163.17 % Running /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/pragmatic.shallow.2.sh for 13 154.02/163.17 % Running /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/pragmatic.ll.e.sh for 16 154.02/163.17 % Running /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/pragmatic.bools.sh for 12 154.02/163.17 % Running /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/pragmatic.bools.1.sh for 9 154.02/163.17 % Running /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/pragmatic.rudimentary.e.sh for 7 154.02/163.17 % Running /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/competitive.strong.sh for 17 154.02/163.17 % Solved by: competitive.strong.sh 154.02/163.17 % Running : timeout 12 /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/eprover-ho /export/starexec/sandbox2/tmp/tmp.Vgg1W6hg4u/e_input58a77e --cpu-limit=10 --auto-schedule -s -p. 154.02/163.17 % done 191 iterations in 7.708s 154.02/163.17 % hashcons stats for terms: size 4096, num 10920, sum length 25962, buckets: small 3, median 7, big 13 154.02/163.17 % proof state stats: {active 88, passive 1678, simpl 0} 154.02/163.17 % SZS status Theorem for '/export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p' 154.02/163.17 % SZS output start Refutation 154.02/163.17 tff(cS_INCL_LEM1_pme, conjecture, 154.02/163.17 (((![R:((a * a * a) > $o)]: 154.02/163.17 ((![Xa:a,Xb:a,Xc:a]: 154.02/163.17 ((((Xb = Xc) & (Xa = c0)) | ((Xb = c0) & (Xa = Xc)) | 154.02/163.17 (?[Xx1:a,Xx2:a,Xy1:a,Xy2:a,Xz1:a,Xz2:a]: 154.02/163.17 ((Xa = cP(Xx1,Xx2)) & (Xb = cP(Xy1,Xy2)) & 154.02/163.17 (Xc = cP(Xz1,Xz2)) & R(Xx1,Xy1,Xz1) & R(Xx2,Xy2,Xz2)))) => 154.02/163.17 R(Xa,Xb,Xc))) => 154.02/163.17 R(w,z,z))) & 154.02/163.17 (![R:((a * a * a) > $o)]: 154.02/163.17 ((![Xa:a,Xb:a,Xc:a]: 154.02/163.17 ((((Xa = c0) & (Xb = Xc)) | 154.02/163.17 (?[Xx1:a,Xx2:a,Xy1:a,Xy2:a,Xz1:a,Xz2:a]: 154.02/163.17 ((Xc = cP(Xz1,Xz2)) & R(Xx1,Xy1,Xz1) & R(Xx2,Xy2,Xz2) & 154.02/163.17 (Xb = cP(Xy1,Xy2)) & (Xa = cP(Xx1,Xx2)))) | 154.02/163.17 ((Xa = Xc) & (Xb = c0))) => 154.02/163.17 R(Xa,Xb,Xc))) => 154.02/163.17 R(x,y,y)))) => 154.02/163.17 (![R:((a * a * a) > $o)]: 154.02/163.17 ((![Xa:a,Xb:a,Xc:a]: 154.02/163.17 ((((Xa = Xc) & (Xb = c0)) | 154.02/163.17 (?[Xx1:a,Xx2:a,Xy1:a,Xy2:a,Xz1:a,Xz2:a]: 154.02/163.17 (R(Xx2,Xy2,Xz2) & R(Xx1,Xy1,Xz1) & (Xc = cP(Xz1,Xz2)) & 154.02/163.17 (Xb = cP(Xy1,Xy2)) & (Xa = cP(Xx1,Xx2)))) | 154.02/163.17 ((Xa = c0) & (Xb = Xc))) => 154.02/163.17 R(Xa,Xb,Xc))) => 154.02/163.17 R(cP(x,w),cP(y,z),cP(y,z)))))). 154.02/163.17 tff(zf_stmt_0, negated_conjecture, 154.02/163.17 (~ 154.02/163.17 (((![R:((a * a * a) > $o)]: 154.02/163.17 ((![Xa:a,Xb:a,Xc:a]: 154.02/163.17 ((((Xb = Xc) & (Xa = c0)) | ((Xb = c0) & (Xa = Xc)) | 154.02/163.17 (?[Xx1:a,Xx2:a,Xy1:a,Xy2:a,Xz1:a,Xz2:a]: 154.02/163.17 ((Xa = cP(Xx1,Xx2)) & (Xb = cP(Xy1,Xy2)) & 154.02/163.17 (Xc = cP(Xz1,Xz2)) & R(Xx1,Xy1,Xz1) & R(Xx2,Xy2,Xz2)))) => 154.02/163.17 R(Xa,Xb,Xc))) => 154.02/163.17 R(w,z,z))) & 154.02/163.17 (![R:((a * a * a) > $o)]: 154.02/163.17 ((![Xa:a,Xb:a,Xc:a]: 154.02/163.17 ((((Xa = c0) & (Xb = Xc)) | 154.02/163.17 (?[Xx1:a,Xx2:a,Xy1:a,Xy2:a,Xz1:a,Xz2:a]: 154.02/163.17 ((Xc = cP(Xz1,Xz2)) & R(Xx1,Xy1,Xz1) & R(Xx2,Xy2,Xz2) & 154.02/163.17 (Xb = cP(Xy1,Xy2)) & (Xa = cP(Xx1,Xx2)))) | 154.02/163.17 ((Xa = Xc) & (Xb = c0))) => 154.02/163.17 R(Xa,Xb,Xc))) => 154.02/163.17 R(x,y,y)))) => 154.02/163.17 (![R:((a * a * a) > $o)]: 154.02/163.17 ((![Xa:a,Xb:a,Xc:a]: 154.02/163.17 ((((Xa = Xc) & (Xb = c0)) | 154.02/163.17 (?[Xx1:a,Xx2:a,Xy1:a,Xy2:a,Xz1:a,Xz2:a]: 154.02/163.17 (R(Xx2,Xy2,Xz2) & R(Xx1,Xy1,Xz1) & (Xc = cP(Xz1,Xz2)) & 154.02/163.17 (Xb = cP(Xy1,Xy2)) & (Xa = cP(Xx1,Xx2)))) | 154.02/163.17 ((Xa = c0) & (Xb = Xc))) => 154.02/163.17 R(Xa,Xb,Xc))) => 154.02/163.17 R(cP(x,w),cP(y,z),cP(y,z))))))). 154.02/163.17 tff('0', plain, ~ sk_R_(cP(x, w), cP(y, z), cP(y, z)), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('1', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X2 : a, X3 : a, X4 : a]: (sk_R_(X2, X3, X4) | X2 != c0 | X3 != X4), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('2', plain, ![X4 : a]: sk_R_(c0, X4, X4), 154.02/163.17 inference('simplify', [status(thm)], ['1'])). 154.02/163.17 tff('3', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_(X1) = cP(sk_Xx1_(X1), sk_Xx2_(X1)) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1)), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('4', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = cP(sk_Xx1_1(X0), sk_Xx2_1(X0))), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('5', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = cP(sk_Xy1_(X1), sk_Xy2_(X1)) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1)), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('6', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = cP(sk_Xy1_1(X0), sk_Xy2_1(X0))), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('7', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1) 154.02/163.17 | X1(sk_Xx1_(X1), sk_Xy1_(X1), sk_Xz1_(X1)) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1)), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('8', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | X0(sk_Xx1_1(X0), sk_Xy1_1(X0), sk_Xz1_1(X0))), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('9', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xc_(X1) = cP(sk_Xz1_(X1), sk_Xz2_(X1)) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1)), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('10', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = cP(sk_Xx1_1(X0), sk_Xx2_1(X0))), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('11', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xc_1(X0) = cP(sk_Xz1_1(X0), sk_Xz2_1(X0))), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('12', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X2 : a, X3 : a, X4 : a]: (sk_R_(X2, X3, X4) | X2 != X4 | X3 != c0), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('13', plain, ![X4 : a]: sk_R_(X4, c0, X4), 154.02/163.17 inference('simplify', [status(thm)], ['12'])). 154.02/163.17 tff('14', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_(X1) = cP(sk_Xx1_(X1), sk_Xx2_(X1)) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = c0), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('15', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1) 154.02/163.17 | X1(sk_Xx2_(X1), sk_Xy2_(X1), sk_Xz2_(X1)) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1)), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('16', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = cP(sk_Xy1_1(X0), sk_Xy2_1(X0))), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('17', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | X0(sk_Xx2_1(X0), sk_Xy2_1(X0), sk_Xz2_1(X0))), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('18', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = cP(sk_Xy1_(X1), sk_Xy2_(X1)) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = c0), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('19', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.17 | X0(sk_Xx1_1(X0), sk_Xy1_1(X0), sk_Xz1_1(X0))), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('20', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X1(x, y, y) | ~ X1(sk_Xa_(X1), sk_Xb_(X1), sk_Xc_(X1))), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('21', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1) 154.02/163.17 | X1(sk_Xx1_(X1), sk_Xy1_(X1), sk_Xz1_(X1)) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = c0), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('22', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xc_1(X0) = cP(sk_Xz1_1(X0), sk_Xz2_1(X0))), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('23', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X0(w, z, z) | ~ X0(sk_Xa_1(X0), sk_Xb_1(X0), sk_Xc_1(X0))), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('24', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xc_(X1) = cP(sk_Xz1_(X1), sk_Xz2_(X1)) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = c0), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('25', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.17 | X0(sk_Xx2_1(X0), sk_Xy2_1(X0), sk_Xz2_1(X0))), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('26', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = cP(sk_Xx1_1(X0), sk_Xx2_1(X0))), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('27', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_(X1) = c0 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_(X1) = cP(sk_Xx1_(X1), sk_Xx2_(X1)) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1)), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('28', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1) 154.02/163.17 | X1(sk_Xx2_(X1), sk_Xy2_(X1), sk_Xz2_(X1)) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = c0), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('29', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = cP(sk_Xy1_1(X0), sk_Xy2_1(X0))), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('30', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_(X1) = c0 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = cP(sk_Xy1_(X1), sk_Xy2_(X1)) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1)), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('31', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_(X1) = c0 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_(X1) = cP(sk_Xx1_(X1), sk_Xx2_(X1)) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = c0), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('32', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = cP(sk_Xx1_1(X0), sk_Xx2_1(X0))), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('33', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | X0(sk_Xx1_1(X0), sk_Xy1_1(X0), sk_Xz1_1(X0))), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('34', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_(X1) = c0 154.02/163.17 | X1(sk_Xx1_(X1), sk_Xy1_(X1), sk_Xz1_(X1)) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1)), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('35', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_(X1) = c0 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = cP(sk_Xy1_(X1), sk_Xy2_(X1)) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_(X1) = c0), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('36', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = cP(sk_Xy1_1(X0), sk_Xy2_1(X0))), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('37', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.17 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.17 | sk_Xc_1(X0) = cP(sk_Xz1_1(X0), sk_Xz2_1(X0))), 154.02/163.17 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.17 tff('38', plain, 154.02/163.17 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.18 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xa_(X1) = c0 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xc_(X1) = cP(sk_Xz1_(X1), sk_Xz2_(X1)) 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xa_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1)), 154.02/163.18 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.18 tff('39', plain, 154.02/163.18 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.18 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xa_(X1) = c0 154.02/163.18 | X1(sk_Xx1_(X1), sk_Xy1_(X1), sk_Xz1_(X1)) 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xb_(X1) = c0), 154.02/163.18 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.18 tff('40', plain, 154.02/163.18 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.18 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.18 | X0(sk_Xx1_1(X0), sk_Xy1_1(X0), sk_Xz1_1(X0))), 154.02/163.18 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.18 tff('41', plain, 154.02/163.18 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.18 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = sk_Xc_1(X0) 154.02/163.18 | X0(sk_Xx2_1(X0), sk_Xy2_1(X0), sk_Xz2_1(X0))), 154.02/163.18 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.18 tff('42', plain, 154.02/163.18 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.18 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xa_(X1) = c0 154.02/163.18 | X1(sk_Xx2_(X1), sk_Xy2_(X1), sk_Xz2_(X1)) 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xa_(X1) = sk_Xc_(X1)), 154.02/163.18 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.18 tff('43', plain, 154.02/163.18 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.18 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xa_(X1) = c0 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xc_(X1) = cP(sk_Xz1_(X1), sk_Xz2_(X1)) 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xb_(X1) = c0), 154.02/163.18 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.18 tff('44', plain, 154.02/163.18 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.18 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xc_1(X0) = cP(sk_Xz1_1(X0), sk_Xz2_1(X0))), 154.02/163.18 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.18 tff('45', plain, 154.02/163.18 ![X1 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.18 (X1(x, y, y) 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xa_(X1) = c0 154.02/163.18 | X1(sk_Xx2_(X1), sk_Xy2_(X1), sk_Xz2_(X1)) 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xb_(X1) = c0), 154.02/163.18 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.18 tff('46', plain, 154.02/163.18 ![X0 : (a * a * a) > $o]: 154.02/163.18 (X0(w, z, z) 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xa_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.18 | sk_Xb_1(X0) = c0 154.02/163.18 | X0(sk_Xx2_1(X0), sk_Xy2_1(X0), sk_Xz2_1(X0))), 154.02/163.18 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.18 tff('47', plain, 154.02/163.18 ![X2 : a, X3 : a, X4 : a, X5 : a, X6 : a, X7 : a, X8 : a, X9 : a, X10 : a]: 154.02/163.18 (sk_R_(X2, X3, X4) 154.02/163.18 | ~ sk_R_(X5, X6, X7) 154.02/163.18 | X3 != cP(X6, X8) 154.02/163.18 | X2 != cP(X5, X9) 154.02/163.18 | X4 != cP(X7, X10) 154.02/163.18 | ~ sk_R_(X9, X8, X10)), 154.02/163.18 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_0])). 154.02/163.18 tff('48', plain, $false, 154.02/163.18 inference('eprover', [status(thm)], 154.02/163.18 ['0', '2', '3', '4', '5', '6', '7', '8', '9', '10', '11', 154.02/163.18 '13', '14', '15', '16', '17', '18', '19', '20', '21', '22', 154.02/163.18 '23', '24', '25', '26', '27', '28', '29', '30', '31', '32', 154.02/163.18 '33', '34', '35', '36', '37', '38', '39', '40', '41', '42', 154.02/163.18 '43', '44', '45', '46', '47'])). 154.02/163.18 154.02/163.18 % SZS output end Refutation 154.02/163.18 % Zipperpin 1.5 exiting 154.02/163.18 EOF